Recipe Feedback:
User Rating 2 out of 5 2 out of 5
(1 review)


Overall Rating: 2 out of 5 2 out of 5
Taste not worth the difficulty!, April 14, 2009
By anjali.

"*Despite the troubles with the dough and its texture, the taste was very nice.*

This was, by far, the MOST difficult dough I have ever worked with! It did not come together after adding the egg yolk. It wouldn't even hold together after being squeezed by hand. I had to add the rest of the egg to bring the crumbles together, then KNEAD it like a bread dough to distribute the moisture.

Rolling it out was frustrating and utterly impossible. I had to press the dough into the pan and use fragments of pressed-out strips to make the lattice. All the extra handling made the dough very tough when it baked. It could only be called flaky because it crumbled like concrete!

I am wondering if this might have worked better if it were approached like a traditional pie crust, with cold butter cut into the dry ingredients. I've never heard of a pie crust that calls for creamed butter and sugar, and now I might know why."